Species 264
Complete lists 2.005
Observers 237
Historical
Species 445
Complete lists 151.729
Observers 6.277
Loading new data...
Overall changes in reporting rate
(2025)
Year-round
Spring
Autumn
vs average
--
--
vs 2024
--
--
Phenology
Phenology across years

Complete lists

2025
2.005
2024
2.393
2023
1.853
2022
1.883
2021
1.071
2020
1.124
2019
1.112
2018
635
2017
454
2016
196
2015
129
2014
129
2013
97
2012
46
2011
59
2010
53
2025
2.005
2024
23.451
2023
19.308
2022
17.718
2021
14.781
2020
14.712
2019
10.026
2018
7.223
2017
5.491
2016
4.840
2015
10.205
2014
9.911
2013
5.663
2012
2.514
2011
1.894
2010
1.987

Records in complete lists (%)

2025
88,2
2024
86,3
2023
83,1
2022
84,6
2021
92,2
2020
74,8
2019
76,1
2018
69,9
2017
73,1
2016
48,9
2015
49,0
2014
71,0
2013
58,1
2012
53,7
2011
67,8
2010
87,1
2025
88,2
2024
79,4
2023
76,6
2022
78,3
2021
82,3
2020
77,5
2019
66,3
2018
65,9
2017
60,2
2016
62,5
2015
63,9
2014
69,2
2013
61,5
2012
54,6
2011
60,4
2010
75,6

Observers

2025
237
2024
252
2023
216
2022
194
2021
83
2020
148
2019
117
2018
101
2017
83
2016
76
2015
72
2014
48
2013
46
2012
39
2011
27
2010
19
2025
237
2024
1.886
2023
1.622
2022
1.224
2021
667
2020
384
2019
682
2018
539
2017
441
2016
369
2015
355
2014
334
2013
302
2012
231
2011
196
2010
184

Breeding evidences

2025
156
2024
775
2023
1.038
2022
2.037
2021
1.339
2020
1.528
2019
1.248
2018
1.676
2017
1.365
2016
1.788
2015
1.726
2014
437
2013
123
2012
92
2011
62
2010
18
2025
156
2024
35.371
2023
32.756
2022
38.002
2021
46.476
2020
43.187
2019
36.542
2018
30.152
2017
37.160
2016
29.427
2015
21.472
2014
10.957
2013
1.892
2012
2.985
2011
2.894
2010
1.835

What's SEE lists?

The overall quantity and quality of the bird data collected in SE Europe is still quite low. For example, relative to its human population, the data collected in this region is about 6 times lower than the European average and several countries in the area are just starting now to develop standard common bird monitoring projects.

SEE lists aims to contribute to fill up this gap by showcasing the value of the complete lists collected by the online bird portals operating in the target countries of the LIFE EBP Reinforcement project in SE Europe: Albania, Bosnia & Herzegovina, Bulgaria, Croatia, Greece, Hungary, Kosovo, North Macedonia, Moldova, Montenegro, Romania, Serbia and Slovenia.

The viewer has three main sections, all of them updated every day with the data collected up to the previous day by the different online bird portals (see here to know more about the EBP data flow system).

At the top, you can see the overall statistics in terms of the number of species recorded, complete lists submitted and observers contributing data. Next, there is the main section of the viewer, where you can see the information at the species level (you can select the species of interest from the drop-down menu) and, finally, on the right, there is the section that shows how data collection and participation has progressed in the area over the years.

Information at the species level

Overall changes in reporting rate

These indicators show the percentage change in reporting rate (% of complete lists with the species) of the year of reference (by default it is the current year but can be changed using the drop-down menu) in comparison with the historical average (2010 up to now) and the value for the previous year. When the current year is selected, given that it will usually still be in course, only the data for the same time period across all years is considered. For example, on April 25, all reporting rates (both for the year of reference as well as the previous year and the historical average) are calculated for the period that runs from January 1 to April 24.

Phenology

Shows the year-round variation in the weekly reporting rates for the year of reference, the previous one and the historical average (2010 up to now). The first week of the year begins invariably on January 1, so weeks do not necessarily go from Monday to Sunday (hover over the values in the graph to see which days are included in each week).

The year-round variation in the reporting rates denotes the overall seasonal pattern of occurrence of the selected species (for example, the time when a migratory species arrives and leaves SE Europe) but can also be influenced by seasonal changes in detectability. For example, many species have lower reporting rates after early summer, once they stop singing, but this does not necessarily mean that their presence has diminished.

Given that the data are updated daily, it is necessary to take into account that the reporting rate of the current week will not always have been calculated with the data for the entire week and, therefore, it may not yet be representative enough​.

Phenology across years

Shows the variation in reporting rates by month and year (from 2010 to the current year).

This is especially useful to see eventual changes in the overall phenological patterns across time. For example, to see if a given species is becoming more or less frequent over the years or at certain​ time periods (e.g. winter). It is also very useful to see which years have been especially good for irruptive species. Like the previous graph, however, it is necessary to keep in mind that the changes in reporting rates can also be affected by seasonal changes in detectability or due to changes over time in the areas or habitats covered by the observers.

Given that the data are updated daily, it is necessary to take into account that the reporting rate of the current month will not always have been calculated with the data for the entire month and, therefore, it may not yet be representative enough​.

Progress indicators

Given that the current year will usually still be in course, you can choose to see the results of these indicators filtered for the same time period across all years (e.g. on April 25, using only data from January 1 to April 24) or including the whole data (i.e. using the data of the entire year in all cases except for the current year).

Complete lists

Shows the progress in the overall number of complete lists collected in the region over the years.

Records in complete lists (%)

Shows the progress in the percentage of records collected within complete lists in the region over the years.

Observers

Shows the progress in the overall number of observers submitting complete lists in the region over the years.

Breeding evidences

Shows the progress in the overall number of breeding evidences reported in the region over the years.

What's a complete list?

A complete list is the list of all bird species that a given observer is able to identify in a given place and time period.

Only very rarely all bird species present in a given place and time period will be detected even by the most skilled observers (e.g. some birds will always be completely quite or out of sight), therefore, it’s perfectly normal for complete lists to only contain some of the species that are regularly seen in a given place and time period.

Why are complete lists so valuable?

Unlike casual observations, complete lists not only contain information about the bird species that have been detected, but also about those that have not been detected. In other words, they give much more valuable information because knowing where birds aren’t detected is just as important as knowing where they are!

Thanks to this, complete lists are particularly helpful when trying to understand the patterns of bird distribution across space and time or to study phenological patterns and their change over time.

The phenological patterns shown in this viewer are just one of the many interesting outputs that can be provided thanks to complete lists.

How could I start to collect complete lists?

Tip 1: Start making complete lists in areas with fewer bird species and more familiar to you (e.g. your garden, a local park).

Tip 2: Start making lists of short duration (e.g. 15-30 minutes).

How can I make my complete lists even more valuable?

Tip 1: Do not move more than 1km (the bigger the area you cover the less valuable the data). If you are hiking or covering longer distances, make complete lists only of some of the areas you will travel through.

Tip 2: Do lists of up to 1, maximum, 2 hours. As a rule of thumb, the shorter the duration and the distance covered, the more valuable the information collected.

Tip 3: Provide always counts for all the species observed, even if they are very rough. It is much better to indicate an extremely rough count than just presence.

Tip 4: If the app associated with your portal allows this, always record your GPS track!

Tip 5: Record any observed breeding evidence.

Tip 6: Collect complete lists all year-round. All seasons of the year are equally interesting!

EBP Partners in SE Europe

Online portals operating in SE Europe